Honda Pilot - Honda Pilot Forums banner

VCM and torque converter vibration complainers...try this

1 reading
21K views 20 replies 14 participants last post by  STMech  
#1 · (Edited)
Ok, sorry for using the term "complainers"! Wanted to get people's attention. This thread is for people who experience vibrations while under light throttle at intermediate speeds and low rpm.

I am extremely confident that people frustrated with pilot vibrations are actually experiencing one of the following conditions:

1.). Normal Torque converter lockup vibration. I say normal because my 95k mile 2004 pilot vibrated under light load and low rpm the entire time I owned it (from new for 7 years.). It's vibrating when it's on the verge of lockup (moderate speeds, low rpm and light throttle position.). If you don't believe me, get your pilot out on a flat stretch of road where you can easily maintain 45 mph with a light throttle in the normal d position on the transmission. Get the truck to get into "Eco" mode. When you get it to start vibrating, shift to "D3". This forces the car to a lower gear and prevents the torque converter from locking up. Once it's settled into D3, lighten the throttle enough so VCM or "Eco" mode is activated again. You won't feel nearly the vibration. In fact, you'll find it's extremely faint if noticeable at all. I think this is 90% of the vibration complaints out there. Now, I'm not trying to tell anyone that there isn't vibration...the torque converter is definitely a chattery one...but it is operating normally and isn't a symptom of a looming mechanical problem.

2.) Low oil level / old oil causing Excessive VCM vibration. I have noticed that my VCM operates much more and kicks in easier right after an oil change. Perhaps one reason I don't experience any excessive VCM issues is due to the fact that I perform frequent oil changes-about every 5,000 miles-due to the fact that I regularly tow a 3600 lb boat and trailer. The VCM system is activated by oil pressure, so oil quality and quantity which can both impact oil pressure can impact VCM system operation.

3.). Bad engine mounts. Likely a few folks...the great minority...have a failed engine mount, which could easily cause vibration problems.

Here's my challenge to those at their wits end with vibration under light loads....don't go more than 5000 miles inbetween oil changes regardless of what that maintenance minder says. Also, try a tank of 91+ octane. The engine, like all modern auto engines, has what's called a knock sensor. It's one of the factors that allows our pilots to run on 87 octane. That being said, it's there for a reason and under high load conditions, the motor can knock or ping occasionally. The engine's ecu will pull timing enough to quell the pinging. Doing so also cuts horsepower, which can make the truck feel a little more sluggish particularly if you have the ac on or have a good load onboard, or are towing. Running higher octane will minimize the situations in which the ecu will pull timing and can help you eek out a hair more gas mileage while maximizing the engines horsepower under a wider range of operating conditions. Here's the important part....it helps the engine and trans operate more smoothly, including the VCM system.

Try these things and report back to this thread. Really give them a shot. I'm confident that a large number of people complaining about vibration will notice a difference in the vibration. At the very least, those that run thru the steps I outlined in item #1 above will see it's not the VCM system, it's just the transmission's normal torque converter operation. :29:
 
#4 · (Edited)
Where do I start...

1) When I disable the VCM by pulling the oil pressure switch, I have no abnormal vibrations. This includes the transmission/torque converter.

With VCM enabled and at around 45 mph, I'll get a very severe shudder when the transmission shifts and VCM engages at the same time. This seems to happen often.

2) I've mentioned the oil deal in a couple of threads. Fresh oil and/or higher viscosity oil does make a difference in my Pilot. I run M1 0w-40 and the VCM vibrations are reduced. As the oil ages, the vibration becomes more severe.

3) My dealer (who has been great) checked my mounts which also included checking to make sure that the rear mount wasn't rubbing on the block.

IMO, all Pilots will vibrate in three cylinder mode on a flat smooth road with a slight incline. Unfortunately, here in FL., that's all we have.
I think the people that "don't have the problem" , don't regularly drive on these type of roads so they don't feel the vibration.

I've driven more than a handful of Pilots and I could reproduce the vibration to varying degrees in all of them. In my Pilot, the vibration can be so severe that ALL of the mirrors will vibrate!

I disconnected the oil pressure switch a few thousand miles ago and the truck drives dead smooth. I use a scan tool to check for codes every week.

And no, neither one of my BMW's vibrate...:)
 
#6 ·
In addition to split71's points: one other data point is that for my Pilot when it is really cold out (-10F or colder and for short trips), and the Pilot does not activate VCM - it drives smooth then without the vibrations (using all 6cyls). So I don't see how the OP's trans/TC theory would explain this. The roads that normally bring out the vibe won't when it is cold enough that the Pilot runs on all 6cyls full time.

I do think the OP has a point with 2) though and oil conditions. I'll be making a change there soon to see if I can affect any change in the vibe amounts.
 
#7 ·
Geo-no, my bmw runs very smoothly!:29:

Trust me, I'm no fan boy of my honda pilot. Our first one (2004) was awesome. This one, we've had all sorts of niggling problems with it. It just isn't built or screwed together all that well.

There are admittedly many other variables that come in to play here, so I'm not here to argue with anyone. You all have good points/positions and who am I to say you are wrong with your own vehicle. One big variable is NVH tolerance. Maybe some of you would get in my pilot and think the vibration was horrible.

Is it possible that VCM is actually the key contributor of the vibration in some cars. You bet. However, I stand by my theory that it's the torque converter that's causing the most issues. How else would you explain how my 2004 (non VCM) also did the exact vibration.

Carboy-regarding your comments about how when it's cold out and VCM is not active you don't get the vibes....torque converter also is slow to lock until it's warmed up. It won't operate normally until full fluid operating temps. If you are making this judgement on short drives, it's not valid. VCM will activate in cold temps...the oil and engine just have to reach full operating temps before it does.
 
#13 ·
Are you also running 91+ octane? Has your dealer inspected your engine/trans mounts? How many miles on your pilot? Have you ever had your trans fluid changed?

Before anyone chops my head off...I'm not saying it's right that some of us have to manage around these issues by extra fluid changes, running premium, etc. I'm just saying these are a few ways you might be able to minimize vibrations. I personally think it's the torque converter on the verge of lockup in most cases (BUT NOT ALL CASES.)
 
#15 ·
Tried 2 and 3, right after I came back from a 6k miles from Missouri to Cali and back, during the trip also run premium for several tanks in a row, not working in my case. I am thinking it could be 1 in my case, so does my service manager however he told me only software update can fix it and Honda doesn't have an update yet. Do you know of any other way to fix this issue?

2012 Ex-L, 12k miles now, oil change very frequently normally under 4k miles, using PP 0w-20 and bosch filter.

Neighbor's X6 M drives like butter but it's out of my price range, I've been negotiating price on X5.
 
#18 ·
I have 2010 Pilot 2wd with 65000mi. I've been suffering from a transmission vibration. Visited two Honda dealerships but they couldn't find the reason. Recently the vibration was getting severe. The symptom is like others. With low torque @1800-2000rpm, steady acceleration or uphill. Even breaking I can feel the converter slip. Also There was shifting shocks when accelerating after slowing down.

The vibration is gone after replacing the transmission fluid. I've done one time drain and refill. I've purchased 4 more bottles today and I am going to do the drain and refill one more time.
 
#21 · (Edited)
The point is that the HONDA 5 and 6 speed transmissions are very vulnerable to dirt or excessive amounts of worn clutch particles in the hydraulic circuits. A drain and fill dumps out 30 or 40 percent of the dirty fluid, replacing it with clean fluid. Repeat the D&F a couple of times to really clean out the system. The point is that if you neglect the Honda transmission, it will just go away--to the junkyard. Don't be cheap, change out the ATF regularly, and the trans should be good for 250k miles.

By the way, if you are having noise or vibration from the rear axle, the first step is to change out the VTM4 fluid. Yes, it is called VTM4 fluid, and you have to buy it from HONDA. New oil is way cheaper than new differentials.