Honda Pilot - Honda Pilot Forums banner

Bug deflector vs. bra

3.7K views 10 replies 9 participants last post by  cwa107  
#1 ·
Just got my 05 EX (I'll post pictures once I figure out how) and am interested in getting a bra or bug deflector.

I bought a half nose bra from autoanything.com and the fit is not that good. It leaves giant gaps between the bra and the car right near where the hood angles down above the headlights. I can only imagine what kind of crap would accumulate in there.

So my questions are:

Does the Honda version of the half bra/mask have this gap (I'm guessing it's more because of the shape of the car, rather than a poorly designed bra)?

How does the bug deflector compare? I know that it's molded to follow the shape of the hood, but not sure if a lot junk can get between the hood and the deflector.
 
#2 ·
The OEM half mask bra will have the same gap. I had the half mask bra, sold it used on ebay and got the Perfect Fit deflector.
 
#5 ·
I disagree:
Once a bra is installed IT CANNOT be removed or you will see where it was, no paint fading underneath, paint "rubbed" underneath, etc.
I had a bra on both my 99 CR-V and my 03 VW Passat and neither showed any signs of "bra damage" after I removed them.

All I did was make sure to put an extra coat of wax in the area of the hood under the bra everytime the whole car got waxed.
 
#6 ·
No Bra!

Since you are in an are which receives snow the roads will be treated with salt and sand. No matter how you wash the bra, small amounts of sand will be in the material. And no matter how tight you make the bra in the garage once on the highway it will move slightly - this works like sandpaper.

I tried everything to prevent this, from constant washing to an extra coat of wax. One the car was a few years old you could see a difference on the hood.

Stick with the OEM deflecter, it come sits high enough to allow you to wash under it and comes off easy when waxing.
 
#7 ·
#8 ·
I agree with the "no bra" folk. My experience with these things is that they will scratch the paint on the hood where they rest. My wife's Toyota had one and there was nothing we could do to stop the slight scratching that occured in the center of the hood from dirt and grime getting under the edge and then working on the paint. Bug shields don't do this, but they are hard to wash behind unless they sit out from the body a ways and then, to me, they look goofy.
 
#11 ·
Congrats on your new '05 - I just got mine about 2 weeks ago.

If you're going to go with a deflector, I recommend the WeatherTech Deflector for the Pilot (http://www.mats.com). The OEM unit is more of a permanent install and many people complain of excessive wind noise/whistling. Installation on the WeatherTech unit requires no tape or any other permanent modification (basically install two plastic grommets and two trim clips) - it looks great too, not transluscent like a lot of them are.

I've also heard many people say that the Perfect Fit deflector is pretty decent, but hadn't ever heard of the company or seen the product.

I'm really happy with the WeatherTech unit, installation took about ten minutes and there is little additional wind noise - but usually not unless you exceed about 70 mph (they ALL make noise, don't believe anyone who tells you different).

I'd also like to echo the sentiment that bras will damage the paint. Even if you don't drive in sandy/salty areas, the constant vibration and rubbing will marr your finish. It might not be terribly obvious, but can reduce your resale value. Why risk it? The deflector performs basically the same function and doesn't require near as much maintenance.

Just my $0.02