Which tires for my 2020 EX-L? Bridgestone or Firestone or something else? And which specific model?
2020 EX-L tire recommendations
TexanPiloteer
21 - 40 of 53 Posts
2020 honda pilot exl with nav and res ,michelin ltx m/s,disabled vcm
Joined
·
315 Posts
There horrible tires you will keep replacing them .but I wouldn't mix tires and different treads .I would buy all 4 it will be better investment later ,stay away from them duelers
Joined
·
65 Posts
Between Firestone Destination and Michelin Defender, which would you recommend? Is there significant difference? Asking because I can get the 1st one from fFirestone which in turn gets me a discount on their lifetime alignment. The Michelin I plan to get from Costco.
Joined
·
65 Posts
Yup, my OEM Bridgestone lasted only 32k miles (well 2 off them at least).
2020 honda pilot exl with nav and res ,michelin ltx m/s,disabled vcm
Joined
·
315 Posts
The Firestones destination wore fast on my old car I got 30k out them and sidewall dried out fast and sucked in rain
If Honda gave me buy 2 get 2 free Bridgestone Duler HP Sport AS, I still wouldn’t buy them.
True, I don’t like overpaying for tires. The problem with 80k mile tires is I’d never use them up before they harden = noisy tires. So I’ve learned to buy 60k mile tires. Not a fan of squishy touring tires.
True, I don’t like overpaying for tires. The problem with 80k mile tires is I’d never use them up before they harden = noisy tires. So I’ve learned to buy 60k mile tires. Not a fan of squishy touring tires.
Joined
·
65 Posts
Between Michelin Defender LTX - M/S and Firestone Destination LE3, which one would you recommend? I am getting both for the same price. Michelin from Costco and Firestone from Firestone.
You’ll have to research the difference between Costco, Sam’s Club, and Discount Tire. I believe road hazard and replacement are included (with installation) with Costco and Sam’s but extra with Discount Tire. Not sure about discounts on alignments or other services. For me, cost would be the major factor as I have Costco, Sam’s Club, and Discount Tire within 5 miles of my house.
If my arm was twisted, the Michelins.
Joined
·
65 Posts
Why only if your arm is twisted?
The Michelins are great! I recommend Discount Tire over Costco because their tire department can be kind of slow.
Joined
·
12,501 Posts
Because he likes Firestone even less than Michelin.
Ask him about his favorite Otani tires.
I’ve had to many bad experiences with Firestone tires.
The Mechelin Defender is a well built tire. I’d never question its quality, but I don’t think this SL tire is worth it’s selling price, nor do I think it to be a great choice for this vehicle. By only allowing me these 2 choices, it’d certainly be an arm twist.
Looks like Costco carries Firestone now might want to ask if you have not.
I prefer Costco only due to the road hazard and future balance/rotate being included.
I had a slight issue with one of the BFGs I bought there and the tech was like, well it's not going to affect performance and we can keep an eye on it but if you're unhappy I'll warranty it anyway. He basically gave me the impression they would take it off and have to "manual adjust it" for the warranty.
It's easy to make an appt, drop the car off, grab a hotdog then wander around the store trying not to buy anything which of course leads to another $300+ bill.
So yeah might be safer the other route.
I have the Michelin Defender LTX. I have had the previous model (just LTX M/S no Defender) and the tread pattern and characteristics are the same for me. They worked well on last model as does the current version for all my needs (towing, beach, gravel, light mud) and the normal quiet good dry and wet.
I have friends that swear by Firestone and hate Michelin and the Destinations work for them in the same conditions I go. Then I also forum debate with Nail Grease
.
Definitely check the road hazard. Discount Tire Direct charged extra for the RH certificates that Tire Rack included in the price. Factor all those in as well as convenience, coverage in places you go if issues, and even shop reputation reviews.
I get tires from Costco, Sams, Tire Rack, Discount Tire direct but you need factor in installation costs etc for the mail order.
I had lifetime balance from Firestone on a Ford Explorer with Dunlop Radial Rover tires that never stayed in balance. I was back monthly. I switched to the Michelin LTX and never had to have them rebalanced after that. I have my normal shop do my alignment when I buy new tires and if I hit a huge pothole or notice odd wear. Some people us the lifetime religiously many times a year. It also gets you back into the shop so they can suggest other services you might need (or don't really yet)
I have friends that swear by Firestone and hate Michelin and the Destinations work for them in the same conditions I go. Then I also forum debate with Nail Grease
.Definitely check the road hazard. Discount Tire Direct charged extra for the RH certificates that Tire Rack included in the price. Factor all those in as well as convenience, coverage in places you go if issues, and even shop reputation reviews.
I get tires from Costco, Sams, Tire Rack, Discount Tire direct but you need factor in installation costs etc for the mail order.
I had lifetime balance from Firestone on a Ford Explorer with Dunlop Radial Rover tires that never stayed in balance. I was back monthly. I switched to the Michelin LTX and never had to have them rebalanced after that. I have my normal shop do my alignment when I buy new tires and if I hit a huge pothole or notice odd wear. Some people us the lifetime religiously many times a year. It also gets you back into the shop so they can suggest other services you might need (or don't really yet)
Joined
·
39 Posts
I got a quote from Costco for the Michelin Defender LTX 245/60R18 for 254.99 each before installation package, tax and fees where as local tire shop quote Firestone Destination LT3 245/60R18 for 196.99 each before installation, tax and fees with additional up to 110 mail-in rebate. Both 70K mile tires. I am considering on going with the Firestone Destination LT3 based on my driving habit and terrain (Northern Virginia). I would say my OEM Bridgestone Dueler H/P A/S is at 60,300 miles and failed passing the inspection due to "cords visible on both front tires" and rec \\ all 4 tires showing secondary rubber" to my eyes it all look Okay and I could use it for another 10K without an issue. Being the local tire shop the place of inspection and also they recommend replacing the 2 tires reminds me the judge and the executioner being the same one, holy crap.
That’s some high prices for a 70k mile tire. 65k mile tires and warranty by NTB or Big O.
![Image]()
I've written and rewritten this a few times.
Long story short, I'm not sure if I'm being fair since I don't really enjoy driving the 330 for more then short trips and I'm looking forward to getting rid of it.
It's a 2017 and well kept but I know any day its going to do something expensive.
So with that:
BFG Advantage T/A Sport XL
They are quality tires, great dry and great wet traction. Aligned once after purchased and left alone. I'm probably due for a rotate and balance but they feel fine.
Been through a couple of extremely wet monsoon type weather where you can only see what's right in front of you, was able to cruise at 40mph and didn't slip or slide. Was actually impressed after that ride.
My biggest complaints are they are loud and they are hard (probably some of this is the vehicle too). Some folks like loud / hard, I imagine many 3-series owners won't mind.
When I was doing my 40+ mile each way commute and my vehicle was not a family car I probably would be happy since traction and treadlife were really the only priorities.
This post makes me feel really old.
Please share photos of your tires. We can help you with how reasonable the request is.
Cheers
One more tire opinion (and I am "Mr Tire-Over-Analysis") especially dedicated winter tires.
Dont over look the Nexen N'Fera RU5 All- Season.
I purchased a set of slightly oversized 18" BMW X4 wheels for my 2011, for a summer setup and these tires came with the deal.
I had never heard of the brand before, but MAN are they quiet! and a very smooth ride
Nexen N'Fera RU5 255/55/R18 about $155
Simpletire.com has 245 review and gives them a 4.2 rating
I cannot tell you how they do in the snow, but I will find out this winter and circle back.
Dont over look the Nexen N'Fera RU5 All- Season.
I purchased a set of slightly oversized 18" BMW X4 wheels for my 2011, for a summer setup and these tires came with the deal.
I had never heard of the brand before, but MAN are they quiet! and a very smooth ride
Nexen N'Fera RU5 255/55/R18 about $155
Simpletire.com has 245 review and gives them a 4.2 rating
I cannot tell you how they do in the snow, but I will find out this winter and circle back.
21 - 40 of 53 Posts
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
