[wkseidel]

We are strongly considering a Pilot EX and are also considering the Highlander (and possibly even the Odyssey w/o the 9 speed transmission). I have recently started hearing more about the new Subaru Ascent with all the news coming out of the LA International Auto Show. Does anyone have thoughts on how this vehicle will compare with the Pilot - pros and cons? So far, the initial information sounds positive - reliable AWD system, solid safety features and good reliability. Thanks!

 

[wkseidel]

As the OP for this thread, I'm fascinated with the opinions and thoughts shared so far...just what I was looking for. It seems that many people are in a similar situation - presently looking for a Pilot-size vehicle - but are open to options in addition to the Honda product. In particular, I will likely follow up with eps105 (via PM) regarding his personal experience with the new Ascent - especially considering that he currently drives a Pilot Touring. Please keep additional comments/opinions coming...very helpful. Thank you.

 

[wkseidel]

I'm the OP from one year ago and wanted to revive this thread for additional updated input. We are still strongly considering the Toyota Highlander LE+, Honda Pilot EX and Subaru Ascent Premium. Our need is for an AWD vehicle to replace our 2000 Honda Odyssey when it dies. It's been an amazing vehicle but now has 223K and is 19 years old. Though not in immediate need, we are doing our homework so we are ready to move ahead quickly when that day arrives (we also have a 2008 Honda CRV AWD). Here's my dilemma: I'm still somewhat partial to Honda but am concerned about the reliability plus VCM concerns, timing belt replacement, and apparent decline in quality. With Toyota, the 3rd seat is small, the 8 speed transmission is not loved, and the design is older... but the overall reliability appears to be intact. Just the other day I test drove a Subaru Ascent and was impressed (features, handling, safety). My concerns with Subaru include the long-term reliability of the new turbo and the CVT plus the fact that it is a first-year design...despite the #1 ranking by Consumer Reports. I read forums on all three vehicles so I realize no vehicle is perfect but want to spend our money wisely since this is a big purchase decision for us. I would appreciate any thoughts on the three vehicles and also if anyone has inside knowledge when the next Highlander re-design will happen (and potential improvements). Thanks for your help.